REVIEWER EVALUATION FORM
blind peer review
Part – A
Reviewer & manuscript details
Reviewer's Name
Reviewer Request Date
Review Return Date
Manuscript No.
Manuscript Title
Part – B
for the Editors
📬 confidential
Editors’ eyes only
these remarks are not shared with authors
Part – C
for the Author(s)
🔢 numbered list required
author feedback
use numbers (1., 2., 3. …) — each point helps author revision
page 2
Final recommendation
1. Unconditional Acceptance
accept
2. Conditional Acceptance with Minor Revisions
minor
3. Revise and Resubmit (Major Revision)
major
4. Reject
reject
Manuscript No.
📄 Part‑A · Part‑B (Editors) · Part‑C (Authors)
✦ single‑blind peer review ✦